Anyone who knows me knows ice cream is my obsession, but then again, who
doesn’t like ice cream? To me, a night isn’t complete without a pint of
Haagen-Dazs or a few scoops of really great ice cream. I prefer a creamier ice
cream made from cream, milk and sugar (Philadelphia-style) or a silky-smooth
custard (French style) ice cream made with eggs as opposed to ones with
artificial ingredients or "gums." That’s why any ice cream shop with a
"homemade" tag under its name attracts me.
Luckily, I live in Hoboken where my need for a cool, smooth "homemade" treat
can be satiated. After all, this town has an ice cream soda named after it: the
"Hoboken special" made with pineapple soda and chocolate ice cream. As legend
has it, the Hoboken special comes from the city’s raging longshoremen’s use of
a "pineapple" hand grenade to intimidate. The city also serves as the
birthplace of the ice cream cone. In 1896, Italo Marciony sold homemade lemon
ice from a pushcart wagon on Wall Street in glasses. The glasses had a tendency
to break or to not be returned, so he invented an edible cone to hold the ice.
In 1903, he patented the cone and sold ice cream from cones in his shop on 219
Grand Street until a fire destroyed it in 1934. Marciony would be proud that
Hoboken has three ice cream shops that make the frozen delight from scratch.
One is the Ice Hut (201 Washington St.). The Ice Hut has been serving the
city its homemade Italian ices and ice cream from its walk-up window for five
years. Richard Irving, who runs the shop, notes that all its ices and ice
creams are fat and cholesterol free. Health-conscious Hobokeners know where to
go for a guilt-free treat without climbing a mountain as runners used to do for
Roman Emperor Nero two thousand years ago. The insane ruler sent them to the
mountains of Italy to get fresh snow to which would be added wine, honey or
fruit for his highness to eat. At the Ice Hut, flavors are more palatable. They
change weekly and include lemon, orange, strawberry, raspberry, lime and more.
Most of the ices are made from natural ingredients except those like pina
colada, which are hard to make with natural flavors. Vanilla and chocolate are
the two flavors of soft ice cream sold here. Ices and ice creams can be
combined for a "cooler," or you can order an "ice shake," which is a shake made
with any flavor of ice.
I come to the Ice Hut when I’m in the mood for a light, refreshing sweet.
Five-year Hobokenite (and my partner-in-ice cream-crime) Sheree Feigelson likes
that all is fat-free here. "I can’t taste the difference," she admits. Another
favorite of ice cream hound Feigelson is Baskin-Robbins, the only non-homemade,
commercial ice cream shop in Hoboken. Opened as "Snowbird" in California in
1945 by Irv Robbins (who later went in business with brother-in-law Burt
Baskin), the store debuted its 31 flavors in 1953. Though not homemade,
Baskin-Robbins has fun flavors and all-around good ice cream. Feigelson swears
it has the best cookies and cream around. The shop has fat-free, lowfat and
no-sugar-added ice creams and sherbets, sorbets and ices.
Back to homemade: Family Scoops (320 Washington Street) makes homemade
Italian ices, gelato, ice cream and yogurt. Owned by Robert McGrath, Family
Scoops has been dishing out yummy, natural frozen treats since last summer. The
spot used to house Flip’s Ice Café, which McGrath owned with a partner for
three years. They made like bananas and split, McGrath opening a shop of his
own under the name Family Scoops with two locations, one in Old Bridge and one
in Hoboken.
The walk-up window in Hoboken attracts drivers, including Carlito Francese from
Riverdale in the Bronx, who stopped by with a friend named Henry for some
soft-serve cones. "It’s quick and easy to get some ice cream," he notes.
While the Bronx boys went for soft ice cream, I’m more impressed with
Family’s unusual flavors like tiramisu gelato, which is addictive. My friend
Ben Slatkin, another ice cream lover, really dug the chocolate hazelnut. The
store has low-fat vanilla and chocolate yogurt as well. Ice cream flavors
include cookie dough (McGrath’s favorite and I like it too—lots of chewy cookie
dough), rocky road, strawberry and cookies and cream (real cookies in here),
and their gelato comes in flavors like chocolate raspberry, coconut, malted
milk ball, pistachio and vanilla chip. McGrath’s gelato is made with milk (no
eggs). He orders the base from Italy and adds milk and flavors (which he
stresses are all-natural). His ices are just as interesting and all-natural:
green apple (for all the martini lovers), cantaloupe, cannoli, banana, passion
fruit, watermelon, lemon and cherry.
"I try to keep flavors more natural with fruit," says McGrath. He mentions a
competitor making ices with names like "moose tracks." He adds, "I use fruit,
no extracts or colorings added. I keep it on the healthy side."
McGrath makes his frozen treats daily in the Old Bridge location and delivers
daily to the Hoboken store. He loves his business. "Everybody’s always in a
good mood when they get ice cream," he says. "They’re treating their families,
grandkids, kids, boyfriends, girlfriends…"
And they’re dogs. Yes, dogs. Family Scoops sells Frosty Paws as well.
Up the street a bit is Hobos (636 Washington St.), which has the look of a
traditional ice cream shop. Unlike Hoboken’s other two homemade shops, Hobos is
open all year. Mary, the owner, says the store churns out 56 flavors of ice
cream though some of the flavors are seasonal. In addition to ice cream, she
mentions the store’s homemade candy as well (check out the chocolate party
favors like the heart-shaped trinket box with lid—all made from white
chocolate). Out front, there’s a huge sign advertising chocolate dipped
strawberries, which the shop sells year-round. Inside, there’s a line of folks
waiting for the unusual flavored ice creams and ices. Its ices include yum-yum
(the old-fashioned term for vanilla and my mother’s favorite), chocolate, pina
colada, root beer, tutti frutti, pineapple and more. The shop also has fat-free
ice cream (in flavors like raspberry and chocolate marshmallow) and sugar-free
(in flavors like peach). It also has yogurt in flavors besides vanilla and
chocolate, like peach. They also have sherbet in flavors like cherry lemon.
(For those of you wondering what sherbet is it’s sorbet—fruit, sugar and
water—mixed with egg whites and maybe some milk.) The big thing at Hobos is the
ice cream, in various flavors like strawberry fudge chip and chocolate brownie
cookie dough. And everyone has a favorite flavor. Mine happens to be caramel
swirl, which is lusciously creamy with just the right touch of sweet caramel.
Mary likes cherry vanilla.
Tim Emr, a one-year Hoboken resident who works in pharmaceuticals, loves
coffee chip. He says, "I really like the consistency and smoothness of the ice
cream."
"I like the hint of chocolate chip and the kick of the mint," says Dave
Briganti, a one-year Hoboken resident who works in market research and loves
the mint chocolate chip.
Italo Marciony would be happy that the shop also has a variety of cones from
which to choose, including regular sugar and waffle to chocolate sugar and
waffle and waffle cups.
But ice cream isn’t the only reason people come to Hobos. Emr says, "Hobos has
a great selection. I like the family atmosphere."
Whether you’re stopping by on a day trip, taking the kids out, enjoying a
walk with a significant other or taking a break from a stressful day, you’ve
got many yummy choices for a sweet treat along Washington Street.
Please send all comments, questions and corrections to
features@hobokeni.com and we'll be glad to forward them.